Speeches

  • close
    Oct. 14, 2006, 05:00

    How to overcome the resistance against medical abortion
    Mirella Parachini, MD
    San Filippo Neri Hospital, Rome, Italy
    OBJECTIVE: To understand how it is possible to overcome the resistance against medical
    abortion in order to improve the right of women to choose.
    RESULTS: Since the introduction of a pharmacological method to induce early abortion
    there has been a strong resistance to it, even in those countries where legal abortion is
    allowed with surgical techniques. Today the question about the choice of the method
    seems to replace the historical debate about the interruption of an unwanted pregnancy 

    among pro-life groups and conservative politicians. Many claim that the “abortion pill”
    makes women less responsible for their behaviour. On the other hand, even among those
    not ideologically against abortion, there is a refusal of medical abortion concerning the lack
    of health care assumed with a “self abortion”. Moreover in some countries abortion clinics
    are refusing to offer it for fear of legal repercussions. Both medical and surgical abortion
    are currently safe and effective when performed by trained practitioners according to
    tested protocols under adequate conditions. However anti-choice campaigners try to
    involve the public opinion and doctors about the risks of the drug, in an attempt to oppose
    the access of the drugs in some countries, like in Canada, Australia and Italy. It is
    therefore necessary to increase the information, considering that any medical procedures
    is submitted to a scientific control, but keeping out of the debate ideological aims to
    maintain restrictions on women’s right to choose.
    CONCLUSIONS. There is a strong resistance at various levels against medical abortion
    and a continuous scientific debate is requested from the abortion providers, beyond
    ideological arguments.

  • close
    Oct. 13, 2006, 02:00

    How to verify success hCG or ultrasound
    Christian Fiala, MD, PhD, Gynmed Clinic, Vienna, Austria

    Objectives: Medical abortion with Mifepristone and Misoprostol is effective in 95-98.6% of
    cases. We compared ultrasound examination and HCG testing to determine the
    effectiveness of the treatment.
    Study Methods: 217 women with an unwanted pregnancy up to 49 days of amenorrhea
    were treated between 26 April and 10 November 1999. They received 600mg Mifepristone
    and 400µg Misoprostol 48 hours later. Expulsion was not verified routinely. An ultrasound
    examination and HCG test was performed on day one and between days 6-18.
    Results: The treatment was successful in 98.6 % of cases. A total of three curettages had
    to be performed; one for continued pregnancy, missed abortion and haemorrhage
    respectively. One patient had a missed abortion but expelled after hormone withdrawal.
    Expulsion of the sac was verified in six patients. HCG levels at the control visit dropped to
    3 % in average (SD 3) ranging from 1-17 % in all cases of successful abortion, with three
    exeptions of 27%, 32% and 44%. The two missed abortions and the persistent pregnancy
    led to an HCG rate of 91%, 159 % and 7900% respectively. 

    Endometrium measured 10 mm on average (SD 4) at the control visit in the cases of
    successful abortion, ranging from 1-24 mm. Diagnosis of successful treatment could be
    based on ultrasound examination in only 66% of cases, owing to the early stage of the
    pregnancy in the remaining cases.
    Conclusion: Measuring HCG level before and after treatment gave a reliable result in
    98.5% of successful abortions, compared to 66% with ultrasound examination.

  • close
    Oct. 25, 2008, 02:00

    Ibuprofen and paracetamol for pain relief during medical abortion

    D.S. Seidman, A. Livshitz, R. Machtinger, G. Yerushalmi, Y. Ben David, M. Spira, A. Moshe-Zahav, L. Lerner Geva, E. Schiff (Israel)

    Department of Ob. & Gyn., Women and children's research unit and Gertner Institute for Epidemiology, Sheba Medical Center, both affiliated to Sackler School of Med., Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel

    Background. Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) have long been avoided in pain relief protocols for medical abortion because of concern over their potential inhibition of prostaglandin induced uterine contractions. 

    Objective. To determine whether the use of the ibuprofen for pain relief is effective and whether it can adversely affect the outcome of medical termination. 

    Methods. In a prospective double-blind controlled study 120 women undergoing medical abortion with 600 mg oral mifepristone and 400 mcg oral misoprostol were randomized to receive ibuprofen or paracetamol when pain relief was necessary.

    Results. Ibuprofen was found significantly more effective (p<0.0001) for pain relief after medical abortion compared with paracetamol. Other parameters that significantly influenced the pain score after administration of the analgesics included the pain score before the analgesia and abortion in the past. There was no difference in the failure rate of medical abortion, and the frequency of surgical intervention was slightly higher in the group that received paracetamol (16.3% versus 8.5%).

    Conclusions. Ibuprofen was found highly efficient for pain reduction during medical abortion and more effective than paracetamol.  We also found that a past history of a surgical or medical abortion was predictive for high pain scores.  Importantly we found that despite its anti prostaglandin effects ibuprofen did not interfere with the action of misoprostol and was not associated with an increase in surgical interventions.

  • close
    Oct. 20, 2012, 11:30

    Dr. Comendant holds a PhD as an obstetrician
    gynaecologist. She is the Director of the
    Reproductive Health Training Center (RHTC)
    of Republic of Moldova, and since 2005 has
    served as the Coordinator of the International
    Consortium for Medical Abortion. In this capacity,
    she successfully supported the development of
    the ICMA regional networks in Latin America,
    Asia, and Eastern Europe. Additionally, Dr.
    Comendant is the National Coordinator of Safe
    Abortion Programme of the Reproductive Health
    Strategy of Republic of Moldova, an attendant
    Professor of the Department of Obstetrics and
    Gynecology of State University of Medicine
    and Pharmacy of Moldova, a regional and
    international trainer in safe abortion methods,
    a senior consultant for Gynuity Health Project,
    USA, and a consultant for the WHO Strategic
    Assessment of Abortion in several countries.
    ICMA: global, regional and national networking to
    reduce the burden of unsafe abortion
    In spite of increased attention to sexual and
    reproductive health and rights, and particularly
    to maternal mortality, in spite of the development
    of effective technologies to make abortion very
    safe, pregnancy-related deaths and unsafe

    abortion remain a major public health problem in
    largeparts of the world.
    There are many organisations working worldwide
    to improve women’s access to safe abortion
    services – through advocacy, law and policy
    reform, capacity building, service delivery, training,
    information sharing and networking. Everyone
    feels there is a growing need to link together and
    combine the efforts towards ensuring the right to
    safe abortion in all the countries. It was agreed an
    international movement is needed to challenge the
    growing threat posed by conservative political and
    religious forces who are seeking to turn the clock
    back, block efforts to improve laws and provide
    services, and exclude abortion from maternal
    mortality reduction and family planning initiatives.
    This is why representatives of several dozen
    NGOs from all world regions, consulted and
    called together by the ICMA and it’s four affiliated
    regional networks (ASAP, EEARC, CLACAI and
    ANMA), in 2011-12, decided to launch the
    International Campaign for Women’s Right to
    Safe Abortion in April 2012, which after only a few
    months has been endorsed by more than 620
    groups and individuals all over the world.

  • close
    Oct. 23, 2010, 09:00

    Impact of legalizing abortion in Portugal in 2007

    Mara Carvalho, Portugal

    In Portugal, in the past February 11th of 2007, 59,3% of the Portuguese voted “Yes” to a new abortion law and a certainty became evident: an important majority of the Portuguese society identified a persons’ autonomy as an ethical principle, ensuring a free and universal access to safe abortion by woman’s request up to 10 weeks of gestation. This legal framework allows you to have real numbers on abortion, thereby being able to identify vulnerable groups, access the implications and interpretation of possible changes over time.

    In this new setting, the estimated numbers were around 20,000 abortions per year, by woman’s request. In a study made by APF - the Family Planning Association - the number predicted was around 17 000. After the implementation of the law the number of abortions by woman’s request up to 10 weeks was similar to predicted (18 014 in 2008 and 18 951 in 2009), about 70% were performed in the public health system and, of those, the medical abortion was the method chosen in 96% of cases.

    Over the past few years have been reported less severe complications (infection / sepsis and
    uterine perforation) related to abortion5. It was recently made public the report of the Maternal Deaths 2001-2007. During this period, in 14 of 92 maternal deaths reported, the cause of death was associated with unsafe abortion. Are not yet published the data of maternal deaths in 2008 -2009, but preliminary analysis indicates that there have been no deaths related to abortion after the legalization.

    Analysing the data we conclude that the big majority of abortions since 2007 were performed in a legal and safe context, the portuguese public health system was capable to properly respond to the abortion requests and regarding the ratio between medical and cirurgical abortion, we realize that medical abortion is the elected method.

    In Portugal, three years after the legalization, it’s still urgent to inform all the women that they have a new right of choice with access to non-directive and specialized support and care, to implement consistent Sexual Education policies and improve the abortion network, including medical abortion performed by family physicians.

  • close
    Oct. 22, 2010, 08:00

    Improving the Provision of Contraception of the Day of Medical Abortion

    Helen Nixon and Audrey Brown, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, UK

    Introduction:

    Annually over 13000 women undergo therapeutic abortion in Scotland. Over 25% of these abortions are carried out in women who have previously undergone abortion. One strategy to reduce the number of abortions is to ensure the provision of reliable contraception on the day of abortion.

    Objectives:

    To describe national campaigns to increase uptake of long-acting reversible contraception, and to improve contraceptive provision at the time of medical abortion,

    to describe a local training programme to achieve the national standards

    to compare the provision of reliable contraception at the time of medical abortion before and after the introduction of the above

    Methods: Case notes of women requesting medical abortion and accessing our abortion assessment clinic were reviewed for a 3 month period in 2007 (n=180) and 2010 (n= 157). Method of contraception chosen at the time of abortion assessment was recorded, as was method of contraception provided on the day of abortion.

    Results:

     

     

    % requesting method in 2007

    % supplied with method in 2007

    % requesting method in 2010

    % supplied with method in 2010

    COCP

    33

    39

    31

    38

    POP

    13

    16

    7

    6

    Implant

    19

    1

    32

    26

    IUD/IUS

    11

    0

    10

    0

    DMPA

    14

    18

    11

    11

    Barrier

    1

    4

    3

    3

    Nil/undecided

    9

    22

    6

    16

    TOTAL

    100

    100

    100

    100

     

    Discussion: Women who choose the oral or injectable contraception are usually provided with the method on the day of medical abortion in both 2007 and 2010. Although 19% of women chose a contraceptive implant in 2007, only 1% of women were fitted with an implant on the day of medical abortion. Several national campaigns, and local projects to enable medical abortion unit staff to fit contraceptive implants, took place during 2008 and 2009. Between 2007 and 2010, there was an increase in number of women choosing a contraceptive implant, from 19% to 32%. In addition, a contraceptive implant was fitted on the day of medical abortion in 26% of women, compared to 1% three years previously. Intra-uterine contraceptive methods are not fitted on the day of medical abortion in our unit. Despite around 1 in 10 women choosing this method, they cannot be provided with their chosen method at the time of abortion. Most women fail to return for interval IUD/IUS insertion, potentially leaving them at risk of further pregnancy. Consideration should now be given  to improving timely provision of intra-uterine methods.

  • close
    Oct. 20, 2012, 04:00

    Increasing access to safe
    abortion servicesMedical abortion with mifepristone and a
    prostaglandin analogue was developed into a
    safe and effective method for induced abortion
    in the 1980’s. Today the prostaglandin analogue
    of choice is misoprostol and medical abortion
    is a safe option for termination of pregnancy
    at all gestational lengths. However, several
    barriers remain that limit global access to safe
    abortion services. Simplifying medical abortion
    could potentially contribute to increased access
    and acceptability. Possible approaches include
    the option to self-administer misoprostol at
    home. Another possibility is task sharing with
    midlevel providers to allow these health care
    professionals to be more involved with the care
    of healthy women undergoing medical abortion.
    This possibility is likely to have major impact
    to increase access to safe induced abortion in
    countries were medical resources are scarce. A
    simplified treatment regimen may also include
    home self-evaluation of complete abortion, an
    option which is currently being investigated.

  • close
    Oct. 14, 2006, 11:00

    Infection related mortality following medical abortion in North America
    Mary Fjerstadt, Clinical Training Director, Planned Parenthood
    Consortium of Abortion Providers, El Cajon, USA
    Among an estimated 560,000 women who have had medical abortion with mifepristone
    and misoprostol in North America, there have been 6 deaths related to infection:
    One death in Canada during clinical trials: C. sordellii
    Four deaths in California: C. sordellii
    One death in western U.S.- C. perfringens
    FDA and CDC held a meeting in May 2006 to discuss what is known and unknown about
    C. sordelii. Since the FDA/CDC meeting and the publication of the article in the New
    England Journal of Medicine about the C. sordellii deaths and mifepristone abortion,
    reports of C. sordellii following spontaneous abortion and childbirth have emerged.
    This presentation will discuss the conclusions of the FDA/CDC meeting, the clinical
    presentation of the cases, the hypotheses that have been put forward to explain why these
    infectious deaths have occurred, and the system of adverse event reporting in the U.S.
    and Planned Parenthood.

  • close
    Oct. 2, 2014, 12:00

    Instability of misoprostol tablets stored outside the blister: a potential serious concern for clinical outcome in medical abortion

    Veronique Berard1, Christian Fiala2 ,6, Sharon Cameron3, Teresa Bombas4, Mirella Parachini5, Kristina Gemzell-Danielsson6 1ICB - CNRS, Division MaNaPI, Département Nanosciences, Université de Bourgogne, Dijon, France, 2Gynmed Clinic, Vienna, Austria, 3Chalmers Centre, NHS Lothian, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK, 4Obstetric Service, Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal, 5San Filippo Neri Hospital, Rome, Italy, 6Department of Women’s and Children’s Health, Division of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Karolinska Institutet and Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden - mparachini@gmail.com

    Objectives: Misoprostol (Cytotec®), is recognised to be effective for many gynaecological indications including termination of pregnancy, management of miscarriage and postpartum haemorrhage. Although not licensed for such indications, it has been used for these purposes by millions of women throughout the world. Cytotec® tablets are packaged as multiple tablets within an aluminium strip, each within an individual alveolus. When an alveolus is opened, tablets will be exposed to atmospheric conditions. The effect of prolonged exposure upon bioactivity of misoprostol and resultant clinical efficacy is unknown. Therefore, this study was undertaken to assess possible changes in tablets exposed to usual European temperature and humidity conditions. Design and Methods: To compare the pharmaco-technical characteristics (weight, friability), water content, misoprostol content and decomposition product content (type A misoprostol, type B misoprostol and 8-epi misoprostol) of misoprostol tablets Cytotec® (Pfizer) exposed to air for periods of 1 to 720 hours (30 days), to those of identical non-exposed tablets. Four hundred and twenty tablets of Cytotec® (Pfizer) were removed from their alveoli blister and stored at 25°C/60% relative humidity. Water content, and misoprostol degradation products were assayed in tablets exposed from 1 to 720 hours (30 days). Comparison was made with control tablets (N=60) from the same batch stored in non-damaged blisters. Results: By 48 hours, exposed tablets demonstrated increased weight, friability, and water content (+78.8%) compared to controls. Exposed tablets also exhibited a decrease in Cytotec® active ingredient (misoprostol) dosage (-5.1% after 48 hours) and an increase in the inactive degradation products (+ 25% for type B, +50% for type A and +60% for 8-epi misoprostol after 48 hours) compared to controls. Conclusion: Exposure of Cytotec® tablets to ‘typical' European levels of air and humidity results in significant time-dependent changes in physical and biological composition that could impact adversely upon clinical efficacy. Health professionals should be made aware of the importance of appropriate storage and handling of Cytotec® tablets.